WHAT'S WRONG WITH ROUNDUP?
EVERYTHING!
Toxicity of Roundup and other Glyphosate Products:
Extensive studies have
linked glyphosate, the active ingredient of Roundup and its many
generic
versions, to cancers, reproductive harm, thyroid disorders, respiratory
illnesses, chromosome changes, and many other ailments.
A
1993 UC Berkeley study found glyphosate to be the most common cause of
pesticide-related illness among California landscape maintenance
workers, and
the third most common cause among agricultural workers.
Roundup
Toxicological profile by Californians For
Alternatives to Toxics
Glyphosate
Toxicological profile by Northwest
Coalition for Alternatives to Pesticides scientist Caroline Cox
Glyphosate
Toxicological
profile by Greepeace
New evidence of Roundup Dangers, article
by Chee Yoke Heong of the Third World Network
Pesticides also contain so-called "inert" ingredients, which are kept
undisclosed, protected as "proprietary" by trade secret laws, and are
frequently even more toxic than the "active" ingredients listed on
the label, and are specifically designed to interact synergistically to
achieve
greater toxicity than each chemical by itself.
Unidentified
Inert Ingredients in Pesticides: Implications for Human and
Environmental Health Cox and Surgan (pdf)
Chemically
Induced Diseases: Synergistic Effects and Cumulative Injuries
caused by Toxic Chemicals Alexander
The
Impacts of Chemical Mixtures - Our Stolen Future
One of the undisclosed, proprietary "inert" ingredients of Roundup is
POEA, a surfactant which is contaminated during manufacturing by 1,4
dioxane.
Metabolites and breakdown products of glyphosate also include
formaldehyde.
Both 1,4 dioxane and formaldehyde are recognized as carcinogens under
Proposition 65.
List
of Proposition 65 chemicals
The dangers of chemical exposure are commonly downplayed with
statements that
the quantities of their poison are miniscule, with pesticide
manufacturers and
legislators going to great lengths to agree on just how much poison is
legally
acceptable to let loose on our environment. But in addition to
synergistic and
cumulative effects of chemical mixtures, some chemicals have a
"nonmonotonic" dose-response, where reducing the dose of the chemical
does not result in a reduction, but an increase in toxic effects.
The
Low Down on Low-Dose
Endocrine
Disruptors
Toxic chemicals can
persist and accumulate in our bodies for years, as has been shown by
numerous
body burden studies.
Body Burden
Articles in the Oakland Tribune
Body
Burden Study by the
Environmental Working Group
Symptoms of Poisoning:
Symptoms
of acute poisoning in humans after ingestion of Roundup include
gastrointestinal pain, vomiting, swelling of the lungs, pneumonia,
clouding of
consciousness, and destruction of red blood cells. Workers have
reported eye
and skin irritation from working with glyphosate. Other reported
symptoms after
exposure to glyphosate include nausea, dizziness, headaches, blurred
vision,
heart palpitations, fever, and weakness.
Emergency
Information in
case of pesticide exposure
Doctors
are required to report both known or suspected pesticide-related
illness within
24 hours, by filling out a Pesticide-Related Illness Report form.
Pesticide-Related
Illness Report Form
Mobility:
Inspite of industry claims
to the contrary, glyphosate has been proven to be mobile in soil, is
measurable
up to 3 years after application, and is spread by rain water run-off.
It has
been found in watersheds, groundwater, and even drinking water.
Roundup
leaching into ground
water in Denmark
Denmark
bans Roundup
Roundup drift is well
established in agriculture, and while industry concerns do not revolve
around
the health of workers and neighbors, what is referred to as crop
"injury"
demonstrates that drift happens, and does so frequently.
Arkansas
Rice Fields Damaged
by Roundup Drift
Alternatives:
If you are insistent on a
more controlled aesthetic, drought resistant ground covers are the way
to go.
They crowd out other plants that may not be desired, while looking
pleasant,
and requiring little care.
If a complete lack of vegetation is required, sheet mulching with
layers of
tightly overlapping, plain cardboard, and a thick layer of wood chips,
suppresses vegetation, without destroying the soil and the organisms
that keep
it healthy.
Sheet
Mulching Photo Tutorial
We recommend a combination of mulching and diverse plantings, and
making
friends with the occasional unexpected "weeds" that volunteer, as well as rethinking how we classify vegetation as "weeds" and "invasives" in general.
So-called "weeds" serve a purpose in nature. They volunteer where
damaged soil cannot support any life except the hardiest. They signal a
first
step towards a return to healthy soil. Pesticides work against you
because they
suppress natural processes, which are not being given their proper time
to
work.
There are other nontoxic options for more conventional "weeding",
including
hand-pulling, which is best timed after rains which make it easier to
pull out
roots, using a weed wrench on woody plants, steam (any portable steam
cleaner
will do the trick, though agricultural versions are also available), or
radiant
heat weeder.
Weed wrench
Radiant
Heat Weeder
Vegetation Management by Public Agencies:
Many municipal Public
Works agencies use Roundup. Oakland, California, has a pesticide
ordinance
thought of by many as a pesticide "ban", but the Public Works
Department is one of the ordinance's many exemptions, and is permitted
to use
pesticides throughout the city. Roundup is one of the herbicides used
especially in median strips here.
PLEASE SIGN THE PETITION TO REVOKE ALL EXEMPTIONS TO OAKLAND'S PESTICIDE "BAN"
You don't need to live in Oakland to make your voice heard. Visitors are also at risk of exposure.
Oakland's Wildfire Prevention Assessment District attempted to add yet another exemption to the city's pesticide ordinance in 2005, but we stopped them.
The East Bay Regional Park District is attempting to launch a similar project in our parks, proposing pesticide use under the guise of "fire mitigation". One of the pesticides proposed is Roundup. In October 2009 we submitted our comments in response to their Draft Environmental Impact Report:
Our comments on the EBRPD Draft EIR for "fire mitigation"
Much to the concern of parents whose children attend the Mount Diablo Unified School District in Contra Costa County, the district uses a generic version of Roundup, applications of which were planned on Fair Oaks Elementary school grounds to begin Wednesday, March 25, 2009.
According to
correspondence with the company, Quali-Pro "The glyphosate in Quali-Pro
is
'essentially similar' (based on strict EPA criteria) to that of
Monsanto.
Monsanto is the basic producer; Quali-Pro is a generic."
Quali-Pro
Glyphosate
T&O Material Safety Data
Sheet (MSDS), which is produced by
the company, and highly biased. While it downplays and claims ignorance
of the
dangers of the product, it does admit that glyphosate is "harmful"
when inhaled.
Quali-Pro
Glyphosate
T&O Label
As
residents of
Meiners Oaks in the Ojai Valley are coping with the onslaught
of
pesticide assaults on their neighborhoods by the CDFA's gypsy
moth program with Btk beginning March 9, 2009,
their watershed is simultaneously scheduled to be contaminated further
with glyphosate by Ventura County and many other
agencies beginning again on April 6, 2009. The Matilija
Dam Project is a program expected to continue for several
years.
A common argument to
support safety claims of pesticide products, is that it they are
registered by
the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), but EPA scientists
themselves have
been protesting for years that chemical industry funding is
compromising their
work.
Chemical
Industry is
Now EPA's Main Research Partner
Monsanto, the manufacturer
of Roundup, has a long history of dishonest practices, and has been
fined
repeatedly because of false claims about Roundup and other products'
safety,
most notoriously Agent Orange. In 2007 Monsanto was fined
in France for making the exact same false claim,
that Roundup
is biodegradable, for which they were already fined in New York 10
years prior.
Monsanto:
A Checkered
History by
Brian
Tokar
The
World According to Monsanto (movie
- YouTube)
Glyphosate
is used by the U.S. Government as part of the "War on Drugs" to douse
one of the most biodiverse forests in the world, causing much suffering
for the people of Colombia:
Shoveling
Water (video - Vimeo)
Links
to many many more
articles about Monsanto and
glyphosate